State ranking
Three New York-headquartered agencies, from a SoHo growth agency for startups to a small-business SEO specialist and a Long Island full-service firm.
New York’s search market is crowded with agencies, which makes fit more important than reputation. A venture-backed SaaS company in Manhattan, a dental practice in Brooklyn and a manufacturer upstate need very different partners.
The three agencies below are headquartered in New York State and each suits a different buyer. For more firms that serve New York clients from elsewhere, see our national SEO agencies page.
These criteria apply our general ranking methodology to this category and market.
| Provider | Best for | Focus | Based in |
|---|---|---|---|
| NoGood | Growth-stage, SaaS and fintech companies | SEO, AEO, Content | New York, NY |
| Main Street ROI | Small businesses and local professionals | SEO, Local SEO | New York |
| Fishbat | Companies wanting content-led SEO within full-service marketing | Content for SEO, Link building, Advertising | Port Jefferson, NY |
Listed by buyer fit, not in order of quality.
Best for Growth-stage, SaaS and fintech companies
Headquartered in SoHo and founded in 2016, NoGood lists SEO and AEO first and runs them inside a wider growth program for B2B, SaaS, fintech and consumer brands.
Best for Small businesses and local professionals
Main Street ROI, headquartered in New York, has provided SEO to small businesses since 2010, especially dentists, attorneys and contractors.
Best for Companies wanting content-led SEO within full-service marketing
Fishbat is headquartered in Port Jefferson on Long Island, with an NYC office, and delivers SEO through strategy and content work alongside advertising and web design.
National agencies. Several national firms in our national list also have New York offices.
Only if in-person meetings or local market knowledge matter to you. For national or ecommerce search, relevant experience matters more than location.
We looked for agencies headquartered in New York State that offer SEO as a meaningful service and suit different buyers, and verified each one’s details on its own website. They are listed by fit, not ranked.
No. Inclusion is editorial. See our advertising disclosure.
State Ohio
Three agencies based in Columbus and Westerville, suited to local businesses, companies wanting SEO with UX and development, and small trades and home improvement…
State Pennsylvania
Three agencies based in the Greater Philadelphia area, suited to lead-generation and ecommerce companies, local service businesses, and smaller firms wanting flexible contracts.
State Illinois
Four agencies headquartered in Chicago and the North Shore, suited to national brands, local businesses, home services contractors and analytics-driven marketers.
State California
Three California-headquartered agencies in the Los Angeles and San Diego areas, suited to ecommerce brands, companies wanting a veteran SEO consultancy, and franchises.
State Texas
Four Texas-headquartered agencies across Dallas–Fort Worth and Houston, each suited to a different kind of buyer, from industrial B2B firms to companies wanting one…
City Miami, Florida
Three agencies based in Miami and North Miami, each suited to a different kind of local buyer, from law firms to businesses that want…